The James V. Forrestal Building in Washington, D.C., viewed from the Smithsonian Castle
Should Washington’s Brutalist federal buildings be preserved or demolished?
The National Civic Art Society, together with the Congress for the New Urbanism Mid-Atlantic Chapter, invites you to attend the public debate "Raze It or Save it? A Brutalism Debate" on Thursday, December 3, 2026.
The event will take place at the Cleveland Park Library in Washington, D.C. (3310 Connecticut Ave. NW, near the Cleveland Park Metro stop). Doors open at 5:30 PM for mingling and conversation. The debate runs from 6:00 to 7:30 PM.
The discussion will focus on Southwest Washington and two approaches to its Brutalist federal buildings: demolish and replace versus save and adapt.
NCAS's collaboration with the Catholic University of America's architecture school offers one vision for redevelopment: replacing these buildings with a cultural district connecting the National Mall to the waterfront through museums, green spaces, and promenades. Advocates for preservation argue that these buildings are an important part of America's architectural history and can be adapted to serve contemporary needs.
Justin Shubow and Catesby Leigh will argue for demolish and replace while Emily Hotaling Eig and Susan Piedmont-Palladino will make the case for save and adapt.
Emily Hotaling Eig is founder and president of EHT Traceries, an architectural history and preservation consulting firm.
Catesby Leigh is an architecture and art critic, and past chairman and research fellow of the National Civic Art Society.
Susan Piedmont-Palladino is a Professor and the Robert L. Turner Chair of Urban Design at Virginia Tech where she also serves as the Director of the Washington-Alexandria Architecture Center.
Justin Shubow is president of the National Civic Art Society, former chairman of the U.S. Commission of Fine Arts, and chairman of the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Beautifying Transportation Infrastructure Council.
We hope you will join us for a spirited discussion about the future of these buildings and the opportunity to create a more beautiful and humane capital.
Admission is free and open to the public. Advance registration is encouraged. The event will be videorecorded for publication on YouTube.
Register HERE (preferred but not required).
